China DOS Union

-- Unite DOS · Advance DOS · Grow DOS --

Union site: www.cn-dos.net Forum site: www.cn-dos.net/forum
DOS stands for freedom, openness and progress. Let us work hard, learn from the openness and GNU spirit of FreeDOS and Linux, and together build and grow a free GNU GPL world!

中国DOS联盟论坛
The time now is 2026-09-15 07:00
中国DOS联盟论坛 » DOS软件下载 & 游戏分享 (下载室) » [Discussion] Which compression software has the highest and best compression ratio View 18,194 Replies 98
Floor 31 Posted 2003-07-04 00:00 ·  美国 肯塔基州 费耶特县 列克星敦 Charter_Communications
系统支持
★★★★★★
“新DOS时代”站长
Credits 27,736
Posts 10,521
Joined 2002-10-09 12:00
23-year member
UID 9
Status Offline
Just use the CABARC command without parameters.
Wengier - 新DOS时代

欢迎大家来到我的“新DOS时代”网站,里面有各类DOS软件和资料,地址:
http://wendos.mycool.net/

E-Mail & MSN: wengierwu AT hotmail.com (最近比较忙,有事请联系DOSroot和雨露,谢谢!)

Floor 32 Posted 2003-07-04 00:00 ·  中国 广东 佛山 南海区 电信
初级用户
Credits 110
Posts 2
Joined 2003-05-11 00:00
23-year member
UID 2005
Gender Male
Status Offline
You have to add the -r -p parameters, thanks moderator
Floor 33 Posted 2003-07-04 00:00 ·  中国 河南 驻马店 联通
金牌会员
★★★★
龙哥DOS
Credits 4,289
Posts 1,501
Joined 2003-02-23 00:00
23-year member
UID 983
Gender Male
From 河南省
Status Offline
The following is quoted from maple's post on 2003-7-4 11:50:17:
Everyone: after trying them out, I've found that the best compression software should be:   PowerArchiver8.5  
  The download website is:   http://www.powerarchiver.com/ &nbsp latest version is 8.5  there are also other Chinese-localized 8.063 versions,
     http://www.crsky.net/down.asp?id=568&no=2  &nbsp
     http://www.crsky.net/down.asp?id=568&no=3&nbsp

 Registration code:
   Name:crsky 
   Code:043345FF

         After my comparison tests :  PowerArchiver8.5  has the highest compression ratio, much higher than the CAB MANAGER
  (including its latest 2003 version)  (not including CABARC.EXE , which I just downloaded and haven't tried yet)! At the same time, PowerArchiver8.5 supports compressing folders, while CAB MANAGER can only compress files and can't include folders, which is very inconvenient!


I've never seen such a good compression program before, with powerful features and outstanding performance. The compression ratio is first-rate!
C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++
C++ ☆☆☆ 中国DOS联盟成员 ☆☆☆ C++
C++ ★★★ 爱提问的红色狂想 ★★★ C++
C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++C++
Floor 34 Posted 2003-07-04 00:00 ·  中国 上海 电信
金牌会员
★★★★
小飞侠
Credits 4,590
Posts 1,812
Joined 2003-04-02 00:00
23-year member
UID 1400
Gender Male
From 上海市
Status Offline
Could you upload it to the forum!
The Chinese-localized version seems impossible to download!
Floor 35 Posted 2003-07-04 00:00 ·  中国 上海 电信
金牌会员
★★★★
小飞侠
Credits 4,590
Posts 1,812
Joined 2003-04-02 00:00
23-year member
UID 1400
Gender Male
From 上海市
Status Offline
Recommended: the best-looking compression software, ACDZIP
I'm using it now to make CAB archives.
At the same time, it also has a function you wouldn't expect: you can use it to view image files inside archives
It really looks great!
ACDZIp1.0 Downloadhttp://nj2.onlinedown.net/down/acdzip.exe
ACDZIp1.0 Chinese localization package downloadhttp://nj2.onlinedown.net/down/Pacdzip.exe
Chinese localization installation password: fxxrp@163.net
Floor 36 Posted 2003-07-04 00:00 ·  中国 香港
管理员
★★★★
專業島民
Credits 4,869
Posts 1,633
Joined 2002-12-10 00:00
23-year member
UID 465
Gender Male
Status Offline
Why not use 7Zip instead, its compression ability is super strong!! And it's Freeware
http://www.7-zip.org/
我的網站:http://mw16.2ya.com/ 我的網誌: http://scrappedblog.blogspot.com/
~
我的Winamp正在播放的歌曲:
Floor 37 Posted 2003-07-05 00:00 ·  美国 肯塔基州 费耶特县 列克星敦 Charter_Communications
系统支持
★★★★★★
“新DOS时代”站长
Credits 27,736
Posts 10,521
Joined 2002-10-09 12:00
23-year member
UID 9
Status Offline
The following is quoted from Roy's post on 2003-7-4 22:43:25:
Why not use 7Zip instead, its compression ability is super strong!! And it's Freeware
http://www.7-zip.org/


Why can't I find a DJGPP command-line version of 7-Zip? Where is it?
Wengier - 新DOS时代

欢迎大家来到我的“新DOS时代”网站,里面有各类DOS软件和资料,地址:
http://wendos.mycool.net/

E-Mail & MSN: wengierwu AT hotmail.com (最近比较忙,有事请联系DOSroot和雨露,谢谢!)

Floor 38 Posted 2003-07-05 00:00 ·  中国 香港
管理员
★★★★
專業島民
Credits 4,869
Posts 1,633
Joined 2002-12-10 00:00
23-year member
UID 465
Gender Male
Status Offline
Compile one yourself from its source code
http://sourceforge.net/project/showfiles.php?group_id=14481
我的網站:http://mw16.2ya.com/ 我的網誌: http://scrappedblog.blogspot.com/
~
我的Winamp正在播放的歌曲:
Floor 39 Posted 2003-07-05 00:00 ·  美国 肯塔基州 费耶特县 列克星敦 Charter_Communications
系统支持
★★★★★★
“新DOS时代”站长
Credits 27,736
Posts 10,521
Joined 2002-10-09 12:00
23-year member
UID 9
Status Offline
I already downloaded the source code, but I don't know how to extract that BZIP archive... Why doesn't the author compile it himself?
Wengier - 新DOS时代

欢迎大家来到我的“新DOS时代”网站,里面有各类DOS软件和资料,地址:
http://wendos.mycool.net/

E-Mail & MSN: wengierwu AT hotmail.com (最近比较忙,有事请联系DOSroot和雨露,谢谢!)

Floor 40 Posted 2003-07-05 00:00 ·  中国 广东 汕尾 电信
中级用户
★★
Credits 417
Posts 137
Joined 2003-05-30 00:00
23-year member
UID 2638
Gender Male
Status Offline
I have downloaded and tried ACDZIP, and its compression ratio is not good!
I also tried 7ZIP, and its compression ratio is also very poor. I don't know what compression software ROY is comparing it with. If you're comparing it with WINZIP,
then there's no need, WINZIP's compression ratio is very low. 7ZIP's compression ratio is a bit better than ACDZIP's in my tests.
So I think the software with the highest compression ratio at present is PowerArchiver8.5 (when the compression format is set to CAB) ; of course, the CABARC recommended by Wengier, after testing, has the same compression ratio as PowerArchiver8.5, but its operation method is very inconvenient, since you have to use DOS commands, and you have to remember all those commands, which is not as convenient as PowerArchiver8.5. The command for CABARC to compress directories is like the following command: cabarc -m lzx:21 -r -p n nc5.cab c:\nc5\*.*
-m lzx:21 sets the compression ratio 15:21 can be selected
-r -p means directories and subdirectories
n is the create new archive option
nc5.cab is the destination filename to be compressed
c :\nc5\*.* is the source filename and path to be compressed

Hard to remember, right?!
CAB MANAGER is also quite a good program! I recommend using PowerArchiver8.5 to compress into CAB format.
That way when you're under DOS you can also use the EXTRACT command to extract under DOS!
Floor 41 Posted 2003-07-05 00:00 ·  中国 上海 电信
金牌会员
★★★★
小飞侠
Credits 4,590
Posts 1,812
Joined 2003-04-02 00:00
23-year member
UID 1400
Gender Male
From 上海市
Status Offline
The reason ACDzip-made archives don't have a high compression ratio is because you don't know how to set it!
Whether it's PowerArchiver8.5, ACDZIP, CABARC, or winace,
the compression ratio of the CAB archives they create should all be the same,
because the compression engine they use is actually the same one!
Microsoft has not made its CAB compression core public!
The reason the programs above can create CAB files is only because they call the core engine.
The reason why PowerArchiver8.5 has a higher compression ratio than other compression software is because
its default compression option is just set to the highest compression ratio!
Also, the reason the files you compress with ACDzip are relatively large
is because you didn't set its default compression ratio!
Though it is rather hard to find
In the pull-down menu under tools, choose the convert archive option
then select the CAB file
then click mpression settings
finally choose LZX21 and that's it!


Also, if every time you want to directly use CAB packaging,
then in the pull-down menu under tools, in the options item,
just set the default archive option to CAB files,
and another thing to note is that ACDZIP's general default options are all set for speed first,
so even with the above settings its speed is still the fastest among these programs!
That's the real real reason why I've always used ACDZIP to package CAB files!
Floor 42 Posted 2003-07-07 00:00 ·  中国 广东 汕尾 电信
中级用户
★★
Credits 417
Posts 137
Joined 2003-05-30 00:00
23-year member
UID 2638
Gender Male
Status Offline
Thanks for Shen Jie's tip. I've already chosen the maximum compression ratio when compressing with all compression software,
PowerArchiver8.5 has the highest compression ratio when compressing (same as CABARC), while ACDZIP's compression ratio, after I used Shen Jie's method (mpression settings choose LZX21, format as CAB), still produced quite a large file after compression, much worse than PowerArchiver8.5. winace when compressing to CAB at maximum compression ratio is the same as cabinet manager 2003 . Shen Jie said: "PowerArchiver8.5, ACDZIP, CABARC, and winace should all have the same compression ratio for the CAB archives they create, because the compression engine they use is actually the same one", I can't confirm that, but when everyone chooses the maximum compression ratio (format as CAB), there really are differences in the final compression ratio. Of course, I found that sometimes using a medium compression ratio first actually makes the file smaller than when using maximum compression, probably because of differences in the algorithm, and possibly also because the file types being tested are different, so different compression software calculates differently. It may also be because different software uses different algorithms for different types of formats.
Floor 43 Posted 2003-07-07 00:00 ·  中国 黑龙江 哈尔滨 联通
初级用户
Credits 107
Posts 1
Joined 2003-07-07 00:00
23-year member
UID 6534
Gender Male
Status Offline
Let me correct something: cabinet manager 2003 and PowerArchiver8.5 have basically the same compression ratio, and cabinet manager 2003 supports compressing subdirectories.
1 .First, set cabinet manager 2003's compression ratio to: LZX 21,Threshold=2147483647(maximum value). This makes it the same as PowerArchiver8.5's compression ratio.
2 .As for subdirectories, it's actually very simple: just drag the files or folders to be compressed (subfolders) onto the cabinet manager 2003 window.^^
Floor 44 Posted 2003-07-08 00:00 ·  中国 上海 电信
金牌会员
★★★★
小飞侠
Credits 4,590
Posts 1,812
Joined 2003-04-02 00:00
23-year member
UID 1400
Gender Male
From 上海市
Status Offline
It's just as jiniang said!
It's only that your Threshold=2147483647 option wasn't set!
The reason ACDZip's compression ratio isn't high is that it doesn't have this option,
so its compression ratio is the lowest,
but have you noticed that its speed is also the fastest among these few!
And at the same time it's also the only one that can be used to view images inside compressed files!
Floor 45 Posted 2003-07-08 00:00 ·  中国 山西 临汾 联通
初级用户
Credits 194
Posts 25
Joined 2003-06-16 00:00
23-year member
UID 5288
Gender Male
Status Offline
Actually everyone can try uharc because I found that many games use it for compression and it's called the strongest compressor
Forum Jump: