China DOS Union

In just two short days, there are again piles of poor-quality posts. NND, I'm fed up and ready to take tough measures. This time, I won't stop until it's in an uproar.

Why not open an elite sub-forum! ! ! Specifically for discussing advanced functions!

Severe times call for severe measures. Moderators, quickly come up with the trump card!

In a fit of anger, sometimes one might inadvertently make a wrong cut.

The moderator HAT is really serious. There are these post regulations attached after the departure. I have also managed forums. I understand those clickbait titles. Oh, it should really be managed well!

Next time, add a special item at the registration, "New members who have read 'The Wisdom of Asking Questions' and '[Recommended for Newcomers] Batch Processing Newcomer FAQ Compilation' should submit a reflection of more than 100 words", maybe this can reduce a bit

I saw the title "Experts please come in, noobs get out" and I was really sad!

See such a title, please report to the moderator, and be sure to deduct his/her points seriously.

Maybe you are an expert
Maybe your expression ability is very clear

But if you are a novice, and the concept of a certain problem is not clear
So that you can't clearly express your doubts
I think most people who ask for help don't just not want to write the title clearly
But they don't know how to write it to appear clear and clear in the eyes of your experts

Who hasn't come from a novice? Haven't you asked for help when you were a novice?
Maybe a very simple problem for you, a certain novice is still struggling with it for a long time
Don't measure others by your own standards

[ Last edited by landays on 2008-10-5 at 18:30 ]

Originally posted by Evangel at 2008-10-4 04:23 PM:
Next time, add a special item at the registration place: "New members who have read "The Wisdom of Asking Questions" and " Batch Processing Newcomer FAQ Compilation" should submit a reflection of more than 100 words", maybe this can reduce a bit

Amazing, amazing
Heard for the first time that a reflection needs to be written

Originally posted by landays at 2008-10-5 06:28 PM:
Maybe you are a master
Maybe your expression ability is very clear

But if it is a novice, and the concept of a certain problem is not clear
So that you can't clearly express your doubts
I think most people asking for help don't not want to write the title clearly
But they don't know how to write it to appear clear and clear in the eyes of you such masters

Who hasn't come from a novice? Did you not ask for help when you were a novice?
Maybe for you a very simple problem, a certain novice is still struggling for a long time
Don't measure others by your own standards

　　After more than half a year, looking back at the post I posted at the beginning, I can't help but sigh: There are thousands of forums, thousands of posts, and the successive bad posts are so similar!

　　I admit that there are some posts with vague titles, because the owner is at a loss due to vague concepts, but, in most cases, the essence of the problem is not that the concept of the problem is not clear, but that many people have been spoiled by loose forum management measures, and are used to posting posts without thinking, typical posting without thinking, look at those titles like "Masters Enter", "Noobs Ask for Help", "Questions about某某", etc., aren't they the majority in the forum? Is it that they don't want to write clearly? They didn't even realize how important it is to write a good title, and how much trouble a vague title will bring to others! What's more, they do it on purpose! They think about how to make the title more eye-catching: provoking others to earn popularity, pretending to be pitiful to win sympathy, being original to show uniqueness... If you just want to get a code and then turn around and leave, then the vague title has no effect on you; if you still want to further learn batch processing technology, or hope to solve the problem by referring to related posts, do you open each post regardless of everything, or skip the posts you are not interested in and directly check the topics you care about? Or use the forum's search function to search for related posts with similar discussions - if your eyes are full of vague posts, do you have to open them one by one?

　　Everyone is not a master from the beginning, but, can you get a good title, which has little to do with technology - there are many people who don't understand batch processing but are full of literary talent. Spending half a day to solve a problem can't be an excuse to send a bad title casually. If you are also casual and loose, you can't expect others to reply to you carefully, let alone that most of the time, the vague title is a waste of others' time.

　　If you don't ask everyone to write a good title with clear meaning and clear direction, but let bad posts run rampant, over time, how many people will still read posts here? Do you all like posts like "Questions about某某" to fill the forum? Is seeing more high-quality titles just my own standard, or does it represent the voice of the majority of members?

　　If you just want to get a code and then leave, you can post casually as you like, and don't worry about whether others can search it, let alone worry about the eternal infamy behind you; if you still hope to refer to related posts for in-depth research, and when searching, you hatefully think: "NND, such a big forum, why can't I find a related post", then, ask yourself: Is my title vague?

[ Last edited by namejm on 2008-10-5 at 20:00 ]

Hehe:
1. There is a word limit for the title, right? Many times, thinking of a title that can both identify the problem and invite everyone to help must make the questioner struggle for a while.
2. "Experts, please come in" --- Maybe the original poster misunderstood. Generally, "experts" written like this is a kind of address, just like usually seeing a woman and generally calling her beauty, "experts" can be understood as master, friend, big brother, etc.! Maybe you misunderstood it yourself!
3. As the saying goes, ignorance is no crime. Not everyone has the same character and consciousness. It can only be standardized so that everyone has rules to follow!
4. Moderators should manage the forum in a considerate way. After all, people's knowledge is accumulated and learned over time. There is no genius who understands everything from birth!

Originally posted by landays at 2008-10-5 18:28:
Maybe you are an expert
Maybe your expression ability is very clear

But if it is a novice, and the concept of a certain problem is not clear
So that you can't clearly express your doubts
I think most people who ask for help don't want to...

Haha, the moderator lacks understanding... Maybe he drank too much

It is suggested that Brother yaogunbasana lurk in this section for a longer period of time, read the old posts before, and think about why so many real experts left CN-DOS. Maybe you will understand the original poster.